Is Amhara Nationalism and Ethiopianism One Subset of the Other?

Is Amhara Nationalism and Ethiopianism One Subset of the Other?

Ethiopian nationalism is a vision rooted in the aspiration to build a singular, unified nation and state, striving to create an integrated society. Unlike empires that uphold and foster pluralism to transcend state formation, nation-states aim to forge a melting pot of society, blending its diverse elements into a cohesive whole.

For Western countries, with their pragmatic approach to culture and religion, relinquishing cultural and linguistic identities to form a new, multi-faceted identity is more straightforward. However, in countries like Ethiopia and those in the East, culture and religion are foundational to society. Norms and cultures are revered like gods in these ancient societies, and nations often choose war over the destruction of their cultural and religious identities. While most Western scholars believe that empires have fallen, it can be argued that empires are more likely to be encapsulated within states rather than entirely collapsed.

The Case of Ethiopia

Ethiopia, where the Amhara people have historically been dominant, presents a unique case of empire formation. The Amhara, along with like-minded Ethiopians, meticulously crafted the nation's system. Amhara culture is highly competitive and transcendent, limiting the community's desire to assimilate others. The Amhara have little to gain from assimilation but much to offer, making them protective of their proud identity rather than eager to franchise it to others. Their culture is inherently anti-assimilation, focusing on perfecting its own identity rather than transforming others into Amhara.

In forming the Ethiopian Empire, the Amhara allowed other identities to flourish, not only due to their democratic and religious nature but also because they were not interested in others becoming Amhara, fearing it would dilute their strong identity. It is akin to keeping an espresso as an espresso rather than turning it into regular coffee. This characteristic of Amhara leadership allowed other identities to thrive, creating an empire of multiple identities. The shared goal of these multiple identities is embodied in the state of "Ethiopia."

The 1960s Movement

In the 1960s, Ethiopia had few universities and a shortage of local teachers, leading to the hiring of Western lecturers. This period marked the beginning of significant cultural shifts as Western culture and history dominated the academic curriculum, captivating young students with Western ideals. The concepts of empire formation in the West and the East differ significantly. Western notions, which heavily influenced Ethiopian universities, depict empires as entities that assimilate and engulf those within their realm. In contrast, the Ethiopian/Eastern concept maintains that core cultures should not be diluted for assimilation.

Addis Ababa, a city founded by the Amhara, reflects the nature of its creators. Similarly, Gondar, an Amhara city and former Ethiopian capital, reflects Amharan sentiment as an Amhara city offered to Ethiopians as their political capital. It was never contentious for Ethiopians to see cities with Amhara characteristics because most Ethiopian cities were founded by the Amhara. In southern Ethiopia, many people were not sedentary or agrarian, which hindered the development of stable cities and localities. The Amhara, being sedentary and agrarian, founded multiple cities throughout history.

The Oromo nation-building movement emerged as a dominant voice in 1960s Ethiopia. Various Oromo leaders rose to prominence to serve this cause, including General Taddesse Birru, who helped establish the “Meccha and Tulama” association. This organization was not just a civic association but the birthplace of Oromo nationalism and nation-building.

In summary, Ethiopian nationalism and Amhara nationalism represent distinct yet interrelated concepts. While Ethiopian nationalism seeks to integrate diverse identities into a unified state, Amhara nationalism cherishes and protects its unique cultural identity, fostering an environment where multiple identities can coexist. The historical and cultural dynamics between these nationalisms continue to shape the Ethiopian nation and its path toward unity and diversity.

Nation-Building and the Amhara Struggle: A Complex Dance of Identities and Power

The Formation of Oromo Nationalism

The process of nation-building often carries a defensive nature, rallying people around a shared sense of struggle. For the Oromo people, this was particularly potent in mobilizing young Oromos from universities. During the 1960s, students worldwide were eager to embrace ideologies worth dying for, such as Marxism and imperialism. Oromo nationalism skillfully tapped into this fervor, providing a compelling cause for Oromo youth to rally around. At the same time, proponents of Ethiopian nationalism also sought to harness this ideological momentum.

The Case of Ethiopian Nationalism

The author posits that Ethiopia is not a nation in the traditional sense but rather a state with a shared goal among its people, which is referred to as “Ethiopia.” This notion can be considered a form of citizenship rather than a national identity. In the 1960s, young Ethiopian students, with limited understanding of their national identity, conceptualized Ethiopia as a nation in the process of nation-building. They believed that this process involved the dissolution of other national identities into a singular Ethiopian identity.

This belief led to the emergence of three dominant factions: the TPLF (Tigray People’s Liberation Front), the OLF (Oromo Liberation Front), and the EPRP (Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Party), now known as Ethiopianists. All three groups saw the nation-building process as an attempt by the Amhara and Christianity to assimilate all other identities. The TPLF and OLF sought independence from this process, even going so far as to establish their own states. Meanwhile, the EPRP (Ethiopianists) believed that the Amhara should pay for the assimilation they had carried out, claiming that in the process, the Amhara lost their identity while creating an Amhara-like Ethiopian nation. All three factions viewed the Amhara as adversaries.

Ethiopianists and the Amhara Struggle

Ethiopianists have two primary goals: to create a unified Ethiopian identity and to subdue the Amhara, whom they believe they defeated in the 1960s. In a recent article, Prof. Girma stated that the idea of maintaining an Amhara identity should perish before it is too late. Many Amhara do not recognize that Ethiopianists are also their enemies and have been orchestrating the Amhara genocide since the 1960s. These groups have crafted narratives that weaken and stifle any Amhara resistance before it can gain traction.

Ethiopianists are typically of mixed identities and are urban dwellers detached from their ethnic roots. They maintain relevance by keeping the Amhara nation subdued, believing that their borrowed Amhara identities allow them to remain in the spotlight. The rise of Amhara nationalism threatens the existence of Ethiopianists, as the two are seen as mutually exclusive. The writer argues that Ethiopianists are mere copies of the Amhara, claiming to be the founders of Ethiopia, while the true founders are the Amhara themselves. This battle for relevance is complex, and many Amhara mistakenly support Ethiopianist groups, not understanding the deeper

implications.

The Case of Amhara Nationalism

Amhara nationalism has been a significant force in Ethiopian politics since Emperor YukunoAmlak initiated a national project to build the Amhara nation. The Amhara people, known for their history, triumphs, and state-loving nature, now face an existential threat from groups who believe that dissolving the Amhara will lead to a fairer Ethiopia. These groups forget that dissolving 30% of Ethiopia’s population, which comprises the Amhara, would also dismantle Ethiopia itself. For Ethiopia to be fair and democratic, all smaller nations must be respected, particularly the largest, the Amhara.

In conclusion, the struggle between Ethiopian nationalism and Amhara nationalism is a complex interplay of identities, power, and historical narratives.The future of Ethiopia hinges on recognizing and respecting the diversity and contributions of all its people, especially the Amhara, who have played a foundational role in the nation’s history.

The Rise and Struggle of Amhara Nationalism

Amhara nationalism, filled with heroism, economic strength, and great minds, has become the largest movement in Africa in less than two years, fighting against its enemies who are committing genocide. This nationalism has challenged and nearly crushed two anti-Amhara groups, the TPLF and OLF, but still faces a third enemy within the Ethiopianists.

Historical Context: The Role of Ethiopianists

In the 1960s, the Ethiopianists crushed Amhara elites and royals, initiating the Amhara genocide. They continue to pursue the eradication of Amhara nationalism. Their motto is, “Kill their elites and they will disband.” Following the 1960s, the Ethiopianists targeted and eliminated prominent Amhara nationalists, from Prof. Asrat to Com. Assigid M. They accomplished this by wearing the Ethio-Amhara mask, effectively disguising their true intentions.

The Ongoing Struggle

Despite significant advances made by Amhara nationalism, the threat posed by the Ethiopianists remains potent. These internal adversaries, who often promote a unified Ethiopian identity, continue to undermine Amhara's efforts from within. They persist in their agenda to eradicate Amhara nationalism, leaving the community vulnerable to external threats.

Identifying the Internal Enemy

The writer advises that Ethiopianists should be recognized as internal enemies of the Amhara. Those who claim there is an Ethiopian identity are often the same individuals who initiated the Amhara genocide. By weakening the Amhara from within, they create opportunities for other enemies to commit atrocities and plunder the achievements of the Amhara people accumulated over 3,500 years.

Call to Action

To safeguard their future, Amhara nationalists must remain vigilant and proactive in identifying and confronting these internal adversaries. The rise of Amhara nationalism is a testament to the resilience and determination of the Amhara people. However, for the movement to achieve lasting success, it must address both external and internal threats to secure its place in history and protect its cultural heritage.

Is Amhara Nationalism and Ethiopianism One Subset of the Other?